Michael Penix Jr. 2024 Select Rookie Card— Value & Price Guide

Expert Analysis

The market trend for Michael Penix Jr.'s base rookie cards is significantly down, with recent sales averaging $1.00 compared to older sales at $3.50. Given his recent season-ending injury, further declines are possible. Selling now allows you to capitalize on any remaining value before potential further depreciation or increased supply floods the market, especially with the 2025 season already seeing him benched and injured. While he is a first-round pick, the immediate outlook is bearish for his base rookie cards.

Market Analysis & Price Trends

Based on 15 verified recent sales on eBay, the Michael Penix Jr. 2024 Select Rookie Card has a current fair market value of $98.00 with prices ranging from $15.00 to $595.00. This valuation reflects the card in Gem Mint condition. The most recent recorded sale was $5.00 on December 31, 2024.

Market trends show downward movement over the past recent sales vs. older sales, with a -71.4% price change. Older sales averaged $3.50, while recent sales average $1.00, indicating a significant downward trend likely due to increased supply as the product becomes more available and initial rookie hype settles, compounded by a season-ending injury.

Our AI analysis rates this card as a SELL. The market trend for Michael Penix Jr.'s base rookie cards is significantly down, with recent sales averaging $1.00 compared to older sales at $3.50. Given his recent season-ending injury, further declines are possible. Selling now allows you to capitalize on any remaining value before potential further depreciation or increased supply floods the market, especially with the 2025 season already seeing him benched and injured. While he is a first-round pick, the immediate outlook is bearish for his base rookie cards.

Collecting Insights

This card is a Common Rookie rarity, Base variant, from the Select set, released in 2024. Collectors value this card for its unique attributes and market positioning.

Notable features include: Rookie Card (RC), First Round Draft Pick (8th overall), Panini Select set. These characteristics contribute to the card's collectibility and market demand.

Grading assessment: BGS 9.5

As a highly-touted first-round draft pick, Penix's card values are driven by his NFL performance and potential, with early rookie cards reflecting initial hype and future expectations.

Key Features

• Rookie Card (RC)
• First Round Draft Pick (8th overall)
• Panini Select set

Quick Facts

• Michael Penix Jr. was a surprising 8th overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, especially after the Falcons signed veteran Kirk Cousins earlier that offseason.
• He made his NFL debut in Week 7 of the 2024 season and became the starting quarterback in Week 16, showing flashes of his college potential despite a season-ending injury in 2025.
• Penix is one of only three left-handed starting quarterbacks in the NFL, a unique trait that sets him apart.
• His college career was marked by both injury struggles at Indiana and a breakout success at Washington, where he led the NCAA in passing yards and was a Heisman Trophy runner-up.
• Base rookie cards like this are currently trending down, with recent sales hovering around $2.00, making it a 'sell' recommendation for short-term collectors.

Recent eBay Sold Listings

Grading Notes

BGS 9.5

Estimated value after professional grading, based on typical grade multipliers for this price range.

Estimates based on typical grade multipliers. Actual values vary by card popularity, scarcity, and market conditions.

Frequently Asked Questions