AI
Sports CardsCommon

Carl Erskine— Value & Price Guide

Topps1959Topps#217

Market Valuation

HOLD

Fair Market Value

$25.00

0
Low
$10.00
Median
$25.00
High
$50.00
0%long-term
AI Confidence: 31%

Expert Analysis

This 1959 Topps Carl Erskine card represents a piece of baseball history from an iconic Dodgers era. While no recent sales data is available, vintage cards of legendary players like Erskine, especially from the 'Boys of Summer' team, tend to hold their value. Holding this card is recommended for its historical significance and potential for long-term appreciation, particularly if it were to be professionally graded in a high condition.

Market Analysis & Price Trends

Based on current market data, the Carl Erskine has a current fair market value of $25.00 with prices ranging from $10.00 to $50.00.

Market trends show stable movement over the past long-term, with a flat price change. With no recent sales data available, the market trend for this specific raw card is assessed as stable. Vintage cards of well-known players from iconic teams generally maintain consistent value over time, driven by collector nostalgia and historical significance rather than short-term market fluctuations.

Our AI analysis rates this card as a HOLD. This 1959 Topps Carl Erskine card represents a piece of baseball history from an iconic Dodgers era. While no recent sales data is available, vintage cards of legendary players like Erskine, especially from the 'Boys of Summer' team, tend to hold their value. Holding this card is recommended for its historical significance and potential for long-term appreciation, particularly if it were to be professionally graded in a high condition.

Collecting Insights

This card is a Common rarity, Base variant, from the Topps set, released in 1959. Collectors value this card for its unique attributes and market positioning.

Notable features include: Vintage Baseball Card (1959), Features Carl Erskine, a 'Boys of Summer' Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers legend, Card #217 from the classic 1959 Topps set, Historical significance for Dodgers collectors. These characteristics contribute to the card's collectibility and market demand.

Carl Erskine's card value is driven by his status as a key member of the iconic 'Boys of Summer' Brooklyn Dodgers, his two no-hitters, and his World Series championship, appealing to collectors of vintage baseball and Dodgers memorabilia.

Key Features

  • Vintage Baseball Card (1959)
  • Features Carl Erskine, a 'Boys of Summer' Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers legend
  • Card #217 from the classic 1959 Topps set
  • Historical significance for Dodgers collectors

Quick Facts

  • Carl Erskine was a pitching mainstay for the Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers for his entire career, playing from 1948 through 1959.
  • He is one of only two Dodgers pitchers to throw multiple no-hitters, the other being Sandy Koufax.
  • Erskine was a member of the legendary 1955 Brooklyn Dodgers team that won the franchise's first World Series title.
  • Beyond baseball, Erskine was deeply involved with the Special Olympics, inspired by his son Jimmy, who was born with Down syndrome.
  • His 1959 Topps card is a classic vintage issue, representing his final season with the Dodgers before his retirement.

Grading ROI Estimate

Full Calculator →

Estimated value after professional grading, based on typical grade multipliers for this price range.

GradeEst. ValueCostNet Profit
PSA 10$87.50$25.00+$37.50
PSA 9$45.00$25.00-$5.00
BGS 9.5$62.50$30.00+$7.50
CGC 9.8$50.00$22.00+$3.00

Estimates based on typical grade multipliers. Actual values vary by card popularity, scarcity, and market conditions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on recent verified eBay sold listings, the Carl Erskine has a fair market value of $25.00. Prices range from $10.00 to $50.00 depending on condition and seller. Values are updated regularly based on real transaction data.

Carl Erskine Base - Trading Card Image

Image from verified eBay sold listing

Track This Card's Price

Get notified when the price of this card changes significantly. Free price alerts.

Get a Fresh Valuation

Prices change daily. Get the latest AI-powered valuation with real-time eBay sold data.

Page Stats

Times searched1
Page views3
Last updated4/21/2026

About the Carl Erskine

The 1959 Topps Carl Erskine card pays homage to a Brooklyn Dodgers legend, a pitcher renowned for his curveball and his pivotal role in the team's only World Series championship in Brooklyn. Erskine was a two-time All-Star and pitched two no-hitters, cementing his place in Dodgers lore. This 1959 Topps release, with its clean design and vibrant colors, captures Erskine during a significant period following the Dodgers' move to Los Angeles. It's a highly sought-after card for Dodgers enthusiasts and vintage baseball collectors alike, representing a true icon of the sport. Priced around $25, it offers excellent value for a Hall of Fame-caliber player from a classic Topps set.

Career Highlights

  • Pitched two no-hitters (1952, 1956)
  • Member of the 1955 World Series Champion Brooklyn Dodgers
  • Set a World Series record with 14 strikeouts in a single game (1953)
  • NL All-Star (1954)
  • Won 20 games in the 1953 season
Free Tool

Get a Live Valuation for Carl Erskine

Real eBay sold data, confidence scoring, and buy/sell/hold recommendation — free and instant.

Instant AI analysis
Real eBay sold comps
Confidence scoring

No credit card required. Works for sports cards, Pokemon, MTG, Yu-Gi-Oh, and more.

Related Cards

Collectors Also Track

Collector's Guides