Alan Mills— Value & Price Guide
Market Valuation
HOLDFair Market Value
$0.75
0$0.25Median
$0.75High
$2.00
Expert Analysis
This 1991 Donruss card of Alan Mills is a common base card from a mass-produced era, meaning its value is very low. While it holds sentimental or completionist value, it is not a significant investment piece. Holding onto it is recommended as selling would likely not yield a notable return, and there's no indication of future appreciation.
Market Analysis & Price Trends
Based on current market data, the Alan Mills has a current fair market value of $0.75 with prices ranging from $0.25 to $2.00.
Market trends show stable movement over the past long-term, with a flat price change. Based on the player's career and the common nature of 1991 Donruss cards, the market for this specific card is stable with minimal fluctuation. There is no recent sales data to indicate any upward or downward trend.
Our AI analysis rates this card as a HOLD. This 1991 Donruss card of Alan Mills is a common base card from a mass-produced era, meaning its value is very low. While it holds sentimental or completionist value, it is not a significant investment piece. Holding onto it is recommended as selling would likely not yield a notable return, and there's no indication of future appreciation.
Collecting Insights
This card is a Common rarity, Base variant, from the 1991 Donruss set, released in 1991. Collectors value this card for its unique attributes and market positioning.
Notable features include: Vintage 1991 Donruss Baseball Card, New York Yankees Player, Common Base Card. These characteristics contribute to the card's collectibility and market demand.
Alan Mills had a respectable 12-year MLB career as a relief pitcher. His card values are driven by his time with popular teams like the Yankees and Orioles, but as a common player from a high-production era, his base cards generally hold minimal value.
Key Features
- Vintage 1991 Donruss Baseball Card
- New York Yankees Player
- Common Base Card
Quick Facts
- Alan Mills played for 12 seasons in MLB, primarily as a relief pitcher for the New York Yankees and Baltimore Orioles.
- He notably wore jersey number 69 for the Yankees, a unique choice in MLB history, and later number 75 for the Orioles as a motivational reminder.
- Beyond his playing career, Mills transitioned into coaching, even earning Manager of the Year for the GCL Orioles in 2019.
- This 1991 Donruss card is from a period of significant overproduction in the sports card market, making most base cards, like this one, very common and low in value.
- Despite the low monetary value, cards from this era often evoke nostalgia for collectors who grew up during the late 80s and early 90s.
Grading ROI Estimate
Full Calculator →Estimated value after professional grading, based on typical grade multipliers for this price range.
| Grade | Est. Value | Cost | Net Profit |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 | $2.63 | $25.00 | -$23.13 |
| PSA 9 | $1.35 | $25.00 | -$24.40 |
| BGS 9.5 | $1.88 | $30.00 | -$28.88 |
| CGC 9.8 | $1.50 | $22.00 | -$21.25 |
Estimates based on typical grade multipliers. Actual values vary by card popularity, scarcity, and market conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Based on recent verified eBay sold listings, the Alan Mills has a fair market value of $0.75. Prices range from $0.25 to $2.00 depending on condition and seller. Values are updated regularly based on real transaction data.

Image from verified eBay sold listing
Track This Card's Price
Get notified when the price of this card changes significantly. Free price alerts.
Get a Fresh Valuation
Prices change daily. Get the latest AI-powered valuation with real-time eBay sold data.